Leader

Collapse

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Who has sells the best extrication equipment

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Who has sells the best extrication equipment

    Hi,
    Our dept. is looking to purchase all new high pressure extrication equipment. A pump, spreader, cutter, and 2 rams. We demoed with Genesis and did like it but need to know what your opinions are here on firehouse forums. Ideally we would like to get 4-5 manufactures to demo for us but that's not that easy since they are scattered all over the US. We have tried several times in the last few month to get Hurst but no luck. Only Genesis answered our request. Here are a few of my questions - what extrication equipment are you using and are you happy, pros and cons and why did your dept decide to purchase a particular brand over another. Any and all info would be greatly appreciated - (please no sales pitches from salesmen).

    Thank you!

  • #2
    If you cant get someone to sell/demo you a set of tools - just think how hard it will be to get them serviced/repaired
    ?

    Comment


    • #3
      myself have used multiple brands and i like TNT the best.. good controls, friendly reps and lots of power
      sigpicWhos says Fire Trucks cant be YELLOW!

      Comment


      • #4
        My department has used Amkus for 20+ years with zero failures and minimal maintenance/repair. We still use the original 1987 set of tools but in a secondary role.

        We have a Genesis mini-cutter and we like it. We also picked up a used Lukas cutter but haven't utilized it much. I've also had some good training experiences with TNT.
        “I am more than just a serious basketball fan. I am a life-long addict. I was addicted from birth, in fact, because I was born in Kentucky.”
        ― Hunter S. Thompson

        Comment


        • #5
          We use Hurst, and they work pretty well. Perhaps it's just the model we own, but the spreader is humungous, and it weighs a TON. I also don't like the thumb switch control or where it's located- it just seems awkward to me. I am a leftie, though, so that may be why it feels wrong to me...

          When we had the NYS Extrication course, the instructor brought along a van full of all sorts of goodies- inc a brand new Amkus system. I loved these tools! I found the twist throttle type control much more ergonomical. The tools were also lighter, smaller and better balanced, which I felt gave me much more control. They packed PLENTY of power, too. With todays vehicle construction, finesse counts for at least as much as brute force. You really need to use that force in the right place, or you just get a nasty mess of twisted, torn metal, and the door is still jammed shut! ( [email protected]#&ing Volvos!)

          We do also have a Hurst Palladin combi tool which is lighter and more manouverable.

          Haven't used them, but the Holmatro and TNT tools look pretty nice.

          Comment


          • #6
            For myself, i love Holmatro, i love core system and we have a good rep in my area.

            You have to think also which brand use nearby fire dept if you work with us sometime.

            Comment


            • #7
              Fox - where are you located?? This is a highly competitive market. And Genisis gave you your only reply?? Amazing. I guess the other guys don't wanna sell stuff.

              Anyway - my dept uses Hurst. Why? Because when we bought them years ago they were the only game in town. Over the years we got rid of the old heavy stuff and replaced it with the newer lighter stuff. Works fine for us, although we're not that busy, and don't use them real hard. The Hurst hi-pressure line has come out with some nice stuff in reent years.

              Really, all of the major brands are reputable and build decent products. It often comes down to demo-ing the tools and deciding what is good for your needs. Price can also be an issue, as well as service & repair. Good luck in your search.

              (The Hurst E-Draulic tools also fascinate me, but I'd be hesitant to buy them until they have been on the market for a couple years and see how well the work & hold up. )

              Comment


              • #8
                You have no idea what a mistake yuo have made by posting this question. Do youself a favor- research what brands you are interested in seeing on line, see how close the local dealer/service center is to your firehouse and call no more than 2 more out. You will eliminate confusion and overall headaches. Listening to guys opinions on this forum will be the most misleading thing you will ever experience in your fire service career...RUN WHILE YOU CAN!!!

                Comment


                • #9
                  TNT great tools life time warranty

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by laddercompany20 View Post
                    You have no idea what a mistake yuo have made by posting this question. Do youself a favor- research what brands you are interested in seeing on line, see how close the local dealer/service center is to your firehouse and call no more than 2 more out. You will eliminate confusion and overall headaches. Listening to guys opinions on this forum will be the most misleading thing you will ever experience in your fire service career...RUN WHILE YOU CAN!!!
                    Without doubt the WORST advise I've ever seen here.Nearby service is VERY important but so is trying tools to see what best suits an agencies requirements. You eliminate confusion by getting as much detail AHEAD of time as you can,compare notes, THEN try the ones you are interested in on head to head trials. T.c.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      I appreciate all the info. I have a NFPA "score card" from Genesis. Where can I find NFPA scores of all manufactures of extrication equipment? I went to NFPA web site but it looks like you need to pay a subscription to view the info.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by desertfox2 View Post
                        I appreciate all the info. I have a NFPA "score card" from Genesis. Where can I find NFPA scores of all manufactures of extrication equipment? I went to NFPA web site but it looks like you need to pay a subscription to view the info.
                        Along with Genesis, TNT, Hurst, Amkus and Holmatro all have NFPA 1936 ratings of their tools listed on their websites and in most of their literature. If you visit each of their individual websites and view the specs on the individual tools (cutters, spreaders, etc.) you should be able to easily find each of their specific NFPA 1936 ratings.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Originally posted by desertfox2 View Post
                          I appreciate all the info. I have a NFPA "score card" from Genesis. Where can I find NFPA scores of all manufactures of extrication equipment? I went to NFPA web site but it looks like you need to pay a subscription to view the info.
                          Read what the Nfpa "scorecard" actually amounts to. NOT much that you will be cutting on the street. While it is SOMEWHAT useful info,I prefer to crunch up a few cars and cut them. Results more typical. As steel twists and folds it can add strength you WON'T find in a lab. FWIW T.C.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Originally posted by Rescue101 View Post
                            Read what the Nfpa "scorecard" actually amounts to. NOT much that you will be cutting on the street. While it is SOMEWHAT useful info,I prefer to crunch up a few cars and cut them. Results more typical. As steel twists and folds it can add strength you WON'T find in a lab. FWIW T.C.
                            Agree with this 100%. The NFPA rating is only part of the process. You need to get the tools in the hands of your personnel for actual hands on evaluations. Have the sales representatives demo the tools for you and then have them leave you tools to conduct your actual evaluations.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              As usual, ejfeicht and Rescue101 are both spot on! Great advice.
                              Smitty
                              Boronextrication.com

                              Comment

                              300x600 Ad Unit (In-View)

                              Collapse

                              Upper 300x250

                              Collapse

                              Taboola

                              Collapse

                              Leader

                              Collapse
                              Working...
                              X