Leader

Collapse

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Keeping our trucks cool, tricks of the trade

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • txgp17
    replied
    Originally posted by FIREMECH1 View Post
    On the direct drive fans, there should be no issue with the "lid" open or closed. But, with the clutch fan, it can create a cooling problem.

    FM1
    Agreed.
    My present truck has a direct drive unit.

    Leave a comment:


  • FIREMECH1
    replied
    Originally posted by txgp17
    This the increased loads placed on the cooling system for emissions, I think it's wise to spec a Jake Brake rather than a transmission retarder.
    No disagreement from me on that one. Never been a fan of tranny retarders.

    Originally posted by txgp17
    Assuming the truck has a proper fan shroud, isn't the fan pulling air through the radiator's cooling fins?
    Yes it does. But there is a difference between the direct drive fans, and thermostatically controlled viscous clutch fans. On the direct drive fans, there should be no issue with the "lid" open or closed. But, with the clutch fan, it can create a cooling problem.

    FM1

    Leave a comment:


  • Rescue101
    replied
    All I can tell you is every rig I've seen around here is registering 250 TRANS temp at operating temperature.Firemech has the #'s as I know them. T.C.

    Leave a comment:


  • txgp17
    replied
    250°F in the sump is when Allison says it's overheating. From the Allison Owner's Manual:
    3.4 HIGH FLUID TEMPERATURE - The transmission is considered to be overheated when any of the following temperatures are exceeded:
    • Sump fluid 121°C (250°F)
    • Fluid to cooler 149°C (300°F)
    • Retarder out fluid 165°C (330°F)
    The section on reduced retarder function begins here.

    This the increased loads placed on the cooling system for emissions, I think it's wise to spec a Jake Brake rather than a transmission retarder.
    Originally posted by FIREMECH1 View Post
    And for what ever reason, keep that damn lid shut!!!! Just because you notice the fan is cycling less with the cab/hood up, you have to remember that you're not letting the fan do its job, pulling air across the radiator to COOL the fluid in the cooling system. You're doing more harm than good.

    FM1
    Assuming the truck has a properfan shroud, isn't the fan pulling air through the radiator's cooling fins?
    Last edited by txgp17; 07-26-2010, 10:27 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • DFDMAXX
    replied
    Originally posted by FIREMECH1 View Post
    Replace ALL fluids annually, except engine oil. Backwash your radiator and all other heat exchangers annually, or semi-annually. Replace thermostats every 5 years. Keep on top of the maintenance, and you shouldn't have any problems.

    Engine temps should be 195 to 210.

    Tranny temps should be 225-265.

    And for what ever reason, keep that damn lid shut!!!! Just because you notice the fan is cycling less with the cab/hood up, you have to remember that you're not letting the fan do its job, pulling air across the radiator to COOL the fluid in the cooling system. You're doing more harm than good.

    FM1
    Actually its not the fan cycling that I notice, the fan is engaged full time when pumping. When I pump more than 60% pump capacity the engine temp rises above 230 and alarms sound. When I open the hood, the temp drops and never gets above 175.

    No, it shouldn't be that way. The truck was spec'd wrong and engineered wrong for this application. All parts working the way they should, checked and double checked.

    That is why I stated that opening the hood works very well on CERTAIN trucks. You can't tell me it doesn't work on these freightliners, just like I can't tell you it WILL work on your trucks.

    If it works, do it. If it doesn't work on yours then don't.

    Leave a comment:


  • FIREMECH1
    replied
    Keeping our trucks cool, tricks of the trade....
    Replace ALL fluids annually, except engine oil. Backwash your radiator and all other heat exchangers annually, or semi-annually. Replace thermostats every 5 years. Keep on top of the maintenance, and you shouldn't have any problems.

    Engine temps should be 195 to 210.

    Tranny temps should be 225-265.

    And for what ever reason, keep that damn lid shut!!!! Just because you notice the fan is cycling less with the cab/hood up, you have to remember that you're not letting the fan do its job, pulling air across the radiator to COOL the fluid in the cooling system. You're doing more harm than good.

    FM1

    Leave a comment:


  • rm1524
    replied
    TXG and DFD - I will try raising the hood or cab and see. I have pump testing coming up the end of Aug. We have never had a problem with one overheating. The fan will cycle, but they do that going down the road.

    Have had the pump panel temp gauge show the truck was overheating but the cab gauge showed within normal range. That was a bad gauge, it showed 100 sitting in the station with everything cold.

    For the tranny I think that 250 is around the normal operating temp.

    Leave a comment:


  • Rescue101
    replied
    Originally posted by txgp17 View Post
    I know the engine can handle it, it's the transmission fluid I'm mainly concerned about.

    When the ATF gets to a certain point, the TCU will cut out the retarder to reduce heat buildup. I'm at a semi-busy station, and a couple of back to back calls gets that ATF up to 250º easy. The last thing I want is for it to cut out right before I have to make a panic stop.

    I wish the truck had a larger heat exchanger for the ATF.I disagree. Every truck I've been on, whether it's cab-over-engine, conventional cab, or custom. When you put the hood/cab up, the cooling fan moves more air. I've gone to far as to time the intervals of the fan clutch cycling while doing a pump service test to verify it.
    Based on MY experience with our Platform(NO tranny retarder)it runs around 250 as well(without PUSHING it).Outside of installing a bigger tranny cooler I don't know what else you can do. Run Castrol Transyn and ask your Allison rep about it but I think you will find 250 is NORMAL. T.C.

    Leave a comment:


  • txgp17
    replied
    Originally posted by Rescue101 View Post
    Don't worry about the 180. That Rig is DESIGNED to operate EFFICIENTLY at 195 every day of it's life. Run cooler, you increase carbon and varnish generation and DECEASE Engine life. these aren't your Grandfathers Diesels,they are designed to run HOT and long. T.C.
    I know the engine can handle it, it's the transmission fluid I'm mainly concerned about.

    When the ATF gets to a certain point, the TCU will cut out the retarder to reduce heat buildup. I'm at a semi-busy station, and a couple of back to back calls gets that ATF up to 250º easy. The last thing I want is for it to cut out right before I have to make a panic stop.

    I wish the truck had a larger heat exchanger for the ATF.
    Originally posted by rm1524 View Post
    As for opening the hood I have to disagree. When you open the hood you are having to pull air around and over the hood to get to the radiator. To cool a motor you need to be getting as much air as possible through the radiator, not around it or behind it.
    I disagree. Every truck I've been on, whether it's cab-over-engine, conventional cab, or custom. When you put the hood/cab up, the cooling fan moves more air. I've gone to far as to time the intervals of the fan clutch cycling while doing a pump service test to verify it.
    Last edited by txgp17; 07-25-2010, 10:35 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Rescue101
    replied
    Guess we're going to have a lovely time disagreeing. I've got three commercial cab Engines(Navistar 2674's)and we're NEVER cracked a hood open(for cooling purposes).......EVER! Comes down to speccing and knowing what you want the vehicle to do. You can pump these wide open for a week at a time and they will never go over 197F.The LAST rig we ever owned that we opened the hood while pumping was our 1939 Diamond T/ Buffalo. Been a few thru here since then and we've never had a problem with overheating Engines. I've also seen some like you describe but of those with problems, most were POORLY specced for application. A Concrete mixer spends quite a lot of time stationary spinning mud and they don't overheat. And many are on Commercial chassis. Spec,spec,spec and DON'T skimp. T.C.
    Last edited by Rescue101; 07-25-2010, 10:54 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • DFDMAXX
    replied
    Originally posted by rm1524 View Post
    Unless you get a high temp alarm there is not a problem. The newer motors run at a higher temp.

    As for opening the hood I have to disagree. When you open the hood you are having to pull air around and over the hood to get to the radiator. To cool a motor you need to be getting as much air as possible through the radiator, not around it or behind it.
    Air is being pulled through the radiator, that is the function of the fan shroud; to make sure the air being pulled through the fan comes from the radiator, not from around it.

    You can disagree all you want, that doesn't change that fact that it works on many of the trucks I deal with. All commercial chassis that were never engineered to sit and pump. They were made to drive down the road with the benefit of the increased airflow to force air in the small grill opening, and help exhaust it from the rear of the engine compartment after travelling through a cramped engine compartment with a low profile hood that doesn't lend itself to interior airflow.

    One might ask why such a cab would be used to build a fire truck out of. I know I asked why, and never got a good answer.

    Leave a comment:


  • rm1524
    replied
    Unless you get a high temp alarm there is not a problem. The newer motors run at a higher temp.

    As for opening the hood I have to disagree. When you open the hood you are having to pull air around and over the hood to get to the radiator. To cool a motor you need to be getting as much air as possible through the radiator, not around it or behind it.

    Leave a comment:


  • Rescue101
    replied
    Don't worry about the 180. That Rig is DESIGNED to operate EFFICIENTLY at 195 every day of it's life. Run cooler, you increase carbon and varnish generation and DECREASE Engine life. These aren't your Grandfathers Diesels,they are designed to run HOT and long. T.C.
    Last edited by Rescue101; 07-25-2010, 10:50 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Tim1118
    replied
    I know you said your newest truck is an '08, so it may not completely apply, but keep in mind that manufacturers are aware of cooling issues, and some of the newer motors will be just fine running hot. Especially with these new emissions, it would be wise to check with either the manufacturer of the truck, or even the engine manufacturer to get input from them. As with a lot of things in the fire service, there may be nothing wrong unless the truck is telling you otherwise. If this is an issue, and by that I mean that it's causing problems or limiting operations, I would get the manufacturers involved.

    Leave a comment:


  • DFDMAXX
    replied
    On a commercial chassis open the hood, this will allow much more air to flow through the radiator.

    This way the fan doesn't have to pull air in through the front grill, and then force it past the engine to exit under the truck.

    With the hood up everything in wide open, nothing to restrict airflow.

    This works VERY well on certain trucks.

    Leave a comment:

300x600 Ad Unit (In-View)

Collapse

Upper 300x250

Collapse

Taboola

Collapse

Leader

Collapse
Working...
X