Leader

Collapse

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Acting at a scene out of district

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Acting at a scene out of district

    Greetings,

    Apologies if this seems a stupid question with an obvious answer. It isn't obvious to me, but that means little.

    I volunteer with the department in the area where I work (and live during the week). On the weekends, I'm about 2 hours away, in a much larger city, that has an all career department. Due to the layout of our two stations, relative to where I work and live, I carry my gear in the car, so I can respond to station 1 from home, and station 2 from work.

    This weekend, I was in the city, heading out for supper, when I came across a (very recent) MVA, where one car had rolled onto its roof. By the time I got out of the car and to the vehicle, there was a group of people trying to flip the car back onto its wheels, by rocking it, which was causing the car to collapse further, and the car was getting quite close to pinning the occupant in place (she was half out of the drivers side window). It took a bit of work, to get the group to stop rocking the vehicle, and to get them to not pull the lady out of the car (she appeared to have a neck injury, and the car was stable where it was sitting).

    In this case, I jumped out of my car and went to the scene, as I was. Nothing on my person indicating that I was a part of any fire department or that I had any training. Would I have been better to grab my turnout coat from the back seat, and throw it on? At the very least, it would signify to those at the scene that I am with a fire department, and hopefully would make things easier, in getting people to back away from the spilling gasoline, not pull the passenger by her shoulders when she has a neck injury, etc. But, when the local department shows up, would it be likely to cause problems with them; ie, would they assume impersonation, because they do not have volunteers?

    I was hoping to ask the battalion chief that showed up, as by the time I the paramedics had taken over the lady (I had bandaged her arm, and was helping with c-spine), the scene had been released to the police, and the fire department was only remaining because they were blocked in by the police vehicles. But, I only had time to introduce myself and answer his questions regarding what had happened, when they got another call, and had to leave. I may make a trip up to the station tomorrow, and see what their opinion is, but most likely I will wait until Monday, and ask the chief of the volunteer department for his opinion.

    But, I was curious as to the opinion of the internet mind, as it were. Also, if I did anything wrong, please let me know - I'm relatively new to the FD world, and just finished FF1 and first responder a couple of weeks ago.

    Thanks in advance,
    Grecko

  • #2
    I have to say that I try not to do anything if I'm out of my area, but based on your description of the scene I would have done the same thing. I can honestly say that my department has never responded to a scene and found somebody in bunker gear, who wasn't a member of the department already on scene. We have had more than our fair share of cops state "I'm on a volunteer department", then proceed to pull a hand-line and try and use it without asking.

    Here in Kansas every department is required to issue ID cards to all members. If i'm on a scene and it's not immediately apparent I'm on the department. (i.e. turnout or department t-shirt) I'll clip my id to my shirt, so that LEOs won't be tempted to tell me to get lost. I've had a state trooper tell me to take my hands off a patient and leave his scene. I responded with, "Sorry, but that ain't happening". He took offense to that and if our rescue truck hadn't shown up about two seconds later and the driver addressed me by name, I think he would have tried to arrest me.

    I have to say congrats on convincing the crowd that you know best, I always have a tough time with that regardless of whether I'm acting in an official capacity or not.

    Comment


    • #3
      Yeah, the bunker gear question can go either way. A couple months ago, we had a couple days when a couple guys from the shift that had just been released witnessed an in-district accident, one moderately serious. The both called 911 and then jumped out and started to treat the PTs. They were dressed in whatever they were wearing home that day (usually short, t-shirts and sandals). Once we rolled up in our bunker gear and in FD vehicles, they handed off the scene and left. I'd say that's probably the best way. If you have someone already giving care to the PT, respectfully identify yourself and then ask what training they have. Who knows, the person pulling them out may be a trauma surgeon from the local level 1 center.

      On a personal note, if someone says they are a doctor, ask what type of doctor. We came upon a seriously active seizing patient and there was a 'doctor' on scene 'treating' them. We kind of let her run the patient until she couldn't make decisions and wasn't really doing any good. We took over care and later found out she was some sort of biomedical research doctor. No real emergency training.

      Comment


      • #4
        I wouldn't necessarily put on a bunker coat but I've made it a habit over the years to keep some sort of easily identifiable jacket, traffic vest, etc. in my vehicles. (Along with a trauma box and a box of nitrile gloves in my primary vehicle.)

        I don't make it a habit of stopping at MVAs unless assistance is clearly needed but it's nice to be equipped and identifiable as a regular responder when I do. Bystanders, drivers in encroaching traffic, and first arriving PD officers respond much better to someone who they can instantly recognize as an ally rather than an impediment.
        "Nemo Plus Voluptatis Quam Nos Habant"
        sigpic
        The Code is more what you'd call "guidelines" than actual rules.

        Comment


        • #5
          I had an almost exact same expereince happen to me.

          I was a chief and emt in a volunteer department in the town I officially lived in. I was also a volunteer fire member in the town where my business was in which was about 80 miles away. I carried complete turnouts and a large trauma bag with me all the time. Now there is a large city that borders the second volunteer departments area and I was traveling to a business center where I had a display set up and I happen to be on my way to it. I also happen to be in a $949.00 charcoal suit and while driving observed a real time, multiple MVA in front of me. What would you do then? Stand by until rescue arrived?

          OF COURSE NOT! You respond.

          I quickly put on my helmet and actually ended up knocking out the glass to get to a unresponsive victim who went a little way down an embankment. Crawling through broken glass to get to him and unbelievably, didn't tear my thousand dollar suit.

          Now when the career fire department and ems arrived, I quickly gave them the results of my primary survey. (I think the male driver was faking being unconscious) and pointed out items that needed to be addressed immediately. (They ran and did it too).

          Soon I realized that the career responders were following my instructions probably because I was the best dressed guy wearing a fire helmet that they had ever seen. I sure have never seen it before and since. It would have been easy to assume I was an administrative officer or other related office.

          But to get back to the original thread, a doctor treats the patient in front of him regardless of race or politics. He treats Osama Bin Laden if he's in front of him. That's not to say he steps in when a doctor is already treating him.

          Emergency responders can do the same if they choose. There are laws in place protecting them if they do act as long as they are not imposing on others jurisdiction and are already on scene.
          Last edited by jam24u; 07-19-2010, 04:55 PM. Reason: 'not' imposing on others jurisdiction

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by jam24u View Post
            I was the best dressed guy wearing a fire helmet that they had ever seen.
            Remember what Nando says,


            "It's not how you feel, it's how you look..."

            You Look Mahvelous
            "Nemo Plus Voluptatis Quam Nos Habant"
            sigpic
            The Code is more what you'd call "guidelines" than actual rules.

            Comment


            • #7
              As a career guy, I sometimes come upon a scene off-duty. It's rare that I'l have my gear with me. If I simply announce "I'm an off-duty FF", instantly most people give me credibility. I think you could use the same, tell them you're a vol. FF, and I think a lot of people will listen. Now, I will say that in some bigger cities where the vol. thing doesn't happen (like here), people might say "so what". In which case just saying "I'm off-duty" first, they'll give you the creibilty and if pressed later, or when the scene is stabilized, explain you're a vol.


              But I also keep a department baseball cap in my truck. I can grab that and sha-zam, I'm identified. I could be any whack job who picked it up from goodwill, but people see it and will think I'm the real deal. That perception is often all that is needed, rather than an official ID or even declaring yourself.
              Opinions expressed are mine alone, and do not necessarily reflect those of the Philadelphia Fire Department and/or IAFF Local 22.

              Comment


              • #8
                I don't carry anything in my car, except a zip up department sweatshirt in the trunk.

                That said, I probably wouldn't think of putting it on. Usually if you step up, speak loudly and sound like you know what you are doing, people will listen to you.
                I am now a past chief and the views, opinions, and comments are mine and mine alone. I do not speak for any department or in any official capacity. Although, they would be smart to listen to me.

                "The last thing I want to do is hurt you. But it's still on the list."

                "When tempted to fight fire with fire, remember that the Fire Department usually uses water."

                Comment


                • #9
                  Stopping Off Duty

                  As a career guy, I sometimes come upon a scene off-duty. It's rare that I'l have my gear with me. If I simply announce "I'm an off-duty FF", instantly most people give me credibility. I think you could use the same, tell them you're a vol. FF, and I think a lot of people will listen. Now, I will say that in some bigger cities where the vol. thing doesn't happen (like here), people might say "so what". In which case just saying "I'm off-duty" first, they'll give you the creibilty and if pressed later, or when the scene is stabilized, explain you're a vol.
                  This is similar to how I handle these situations. I'll stay in traffic (if traffic control has been set-up) and when I get-up to whoever is directing traffic I'll identify myself as an Off-duty FF and ask them if anybody's hurt?

                  While returning home from Texas with my family, my wife (a RN, who was an EMT) and I (Career Fire Captain Local/National EMT) came upon a roll-ever T/C that literally happened (3) cars in front of us; car parts were still flying through the air as we dogged the other cars and parked on the shoulder of the road. We stopped and rendered care since (1) Pt. was self extricated and the other needed extricating due to the damage of the vehicle. A couple of minutes later, a Vol. Fire Captain pulled-up POV and asked what I needed. He even addressed me as "Cap" which was kinda different since I didn't tell him who I was. When the 1st LEO got on scene he came up to the local Vol. FD Captain and asked him what was going on. At this point the Vol. directed him to me, and I advised him that he needed to secure and start to deal with the drugs (later we found out that there were 360 lbs of mexican marijuana) that was flung all over the place.

                  Later into the incident, after the 1st ambulance arrived a "County Mounty" got uppidy with me (he had been on scene no longer than 5 mins, I had been there for about 40 mins or so) when I asked if he could get some of the lookey-loos away so that the Rescue from the FD could get into the scene. After an exchange of words and some "Verbal Judo" on my part, the request was granted and the FD went to work.

                  Initially, I was pretty hot but as I was cleaning some blood that had gotten on me above my gloves I calmed down and went over to the Vol. Capt. and told him what happened just in case there was some backlash towards his Department. The outlook there is that since the Sheriff's are career they have little respect for the Vol. FD. This was different to me, since in all the areas I've worked in, LE has done their job and FD does their job.....

                  The reason why I share this story is to give you a little insight on issues that you may face. Here I was 2,000 miles from home having to deal with some political fallout that I obviously had no part in..... As far as what you did for the Pt. you can never go wrong with doing what you are medically trained to do; with that being said, stay well within your medical training and only perform what you can do with your equipment at hand. Even a calming voice and holding C-spine is enough medical treatment until somebody comes that's a higher level of medical care or you get more medical equipment on scene. As far as having issues with LEOs, my advice is to not argue with a person that carries a gun..... Especially when you're new..... Emotions are good when harnessed and controlled.

                  Well, I'll end this with a "good job" and give you "cudos" for handling the situation and doing what was best for your Pt.
                  "Be LOUD, Be PROUD..... It just might save your can someday when goin' through an intersection!!!!!"

                  Life on the Truck (Quint) is good.....

                  Eat til you're sleepy..... Sleep til you're hungry..... And repeat.....

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    I had a similar experience, before I had started volunteering with my current department I came up on a wreck moments after it happened, two possible ejections, about four cars involved and one possible pin.

                    Naturally I stopped and called 911 as I did a quick check of the scene and figuring out what was going on.

                    I instructed a few of the bystanders to hold bandages to some of the wounds and got one bystander with some first aide training to hold c-spine. After the first engine arrived gave them a run down of what was going on. There were enough patients that I ended up continuing to help out
                    I wasn't wearing anything that identified myself as being with a fire department etc, but did identify myself as an emt.

                    If I had a coat and it was nasty weather out I may put it on or at night but I don't always think that I would wear it just because I came up on a wreck.
                    Brian Irey

                    My comments are mine and mine alone - they do not represent any thoughts or views of my department or anyone else

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Out of District

                      Each fire department regards their response area as their "kingdom". If anyone else happens to be at the scene of a fire, rescue, MVA, medical emergency, etc. they tend to be defensive.

                      Unless the jurisdiction FD knows you, then they tend to "want to know why you are there".
                      Its just a natural reaction and you would probably ask the same question of anyone on scene of an emergency, in your response area.

                      We are there for the patient(s). If you come across an accident and are on scene before the jurisdiction EMS is on scene, then stop and help. You can always show your EMT, etc. credentials later.

                      Most EMS personnel will not have any problems if you render aid before they arrive. You probably have the same credentials that they do. Seconds count when someone is bleeding, not breathing, etc.

                      On the other hand, law enforcement is a different species to deal with on the scene of an accident.

                      Some states have statute(s) that deal with Good Samaritians, Obligation to Render Aid and other laws pertaining to this topic. Research and know these laws. If these laws are in effect and you know them, you can reassure yourself that stopping to help is legal.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        A couple months ago I happened upon a single vehicle MVA right at the same time the local vol. fire dept pulled up. It was at a red light and I could see that there were only 3 guys on the truck and at least 2 patients. I grabbed a pair of gloves and my county name tag and told the OIC that I was an FF/EMT in xxxx County and would be happy to assist in patient care/C-Spine if he wanted. He told me he would appreciate the help.

                        I held c-spine and actually had to tell the FF's to crib the car-- they were starting to pop the door (using a halagan) without cribbing in place. I also asked the EMT (who arrived a few minutes later) doing patient accessment to apply O2 as the elderly patient was disorientated and starting to show signs of LOC. All of this was done.

                        When I was relieved from my post inside the car, one of the FF's grabbed a Hurst 32 and in his hurry hit the EMT in the knee. This of course sent her into extreme pain and it looked like I was the only one who was going to help her, which I did. I called the EMT's employer the next day to make sure they knew that the EMT was doing her job correctly and not at fault. From my accessment of the EMT, it looked like she was going to be out of work for a while and I wanted to make sure she didn't get blamed for this. BTW, I'm a firefighter first, EMT second but this was so unnecessary that it really made me mad.

                        By the way, I left all of my truma gear in my car. I run QRS calls in my township so I keep my car well stocked. I didn't want my stuff to get mingled with another responders equip., especally out of county. My reasoning was that I knew other responders were on the way and If I really needed it I could have asked a bystander (there were many) to get it from my car. I now carry a BLS fanny pack with the basic things for a first response.
                        FF/EMT

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          See,

                          Even when we have had multiple injury events, everyone who is qualified to help is most welcome. I am very glad to see them and really appreciate it when they do. It is a relief to see a person come running up with gloves on, identifies themself and asks if they can help.

                          We take them all,,,,,

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            See,

                            Even when we have had multiple injury events, everyone who is qualified to help is most welcome. I am very glad to see them and really appreciate it when they do. It is a relief to see a person come running up with gloves on, identifies themself and asks if they can help.

                            We take them all,,,,,
                            As a C.O. I'll do the same as long as it's needed. I'll even go so far as to personally observe what the helpers skills are, if they're doing good and seem to have a good grasp then I'll tell them and leave them alone. If I see something that makes me question my decision, I'll reassign them to traffic control or something like that.
                            "Be LOUD, Be PROUD..... It just might save your can someday when goin' through an intersection!!!!!"

                            Life on the Truck (Quint) is good.....

                            Eat til you're sleepy..... Sleep til you're hungry..... And repeat.....

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              I've been witness to a scuffle or two (verbally and physically) over out of area help jumping in and rendering assistance.

                              It is a two headed animal...To those who are caught in the wrong place at the right time- Of course you are going to render help; just do not over extend your stay.

                              To those who find "alien FFs" on your fireground/accident scene- Put yourself in their shoes; Would you provide aid? Be polite, appreciative and ask them to leave (POLITELY) if you do not wish them to assist... But for the love of God, don't bash skulls 'cuz they beat you there first... They probably don't REALLY wanna be there... They are there out of commitment to the principles of the job.
                              A coward stands by and watches wrongs committed without saying a word...Any opinions expressed are purely my own and not necessarily reflective of the views of my former departments

                              Comment

                              300x600 Ad Unit (In-View)

                              Collapse

                              Upper 300x250

                              Collapse

                              Taboola

                              Collapse

                              Leader

                              Collapse
                              Working...
                              X